The Michigan Court of Appeals Rules that Padilla Applies Prospectively Only

ArborYpsi Law

The Michigan Court of Appeals in People v. Gomez was asked whether the United States Supreme Court decision Padilla v. Kentucky would apply to cases that were already decided and ruled that Padilla’s effect would not be retroactive.

In Padilla, the Supreme Court held that criminal defense counsel must advise a non-citizen defendant that a guilty plea may result in deportation. Failure to advise on the basic deportation consequences could be ineffective assistance counsel.

Defendant Gomez was a citizen of Mexico but had resided in America for most of his life. He was convicted of possession with intent to deliver and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony. Four years after Gomez finished his sentence that included jail and probation, he was informed by the Department of Homeland Security that his conviction rendered him deportable.

The following year, the United States Supreme Court issued the Padilla decision.

Related: ArborYpsi Law Blog Post on Padilla v. Kentucky

After Padilla was decided, Gomez attempted to have his conviction set aside in trial court, arguing that defense counsel did not inform him of the immigration consequences, and had he been aware of those consequences he would have instead gone to trial. The trial court refused to set aside the conviction. A defendant will be entitled to relief from a judgment if a retroactive change in the law alters the validity of the conviction.

The Court discussed whether a law applies retroactively under both federal and Michigan law. Under both tests, the Court determined that Padilla should not have retroactive application.

In the end, the trial court was upheld and Gomez was denied relief.

Contact ArborYpsi Law at 734-883-9584 or at bernstein@arborypsilaw.com to speak with attorney Sam Bernstein.

Legal Disclaimer

Client Reviews

Sam was a helpful lawyer who is a man of his word. He helped in our cases 2 times in a row with successful outcomes. I could not think of a better lawyer who is always on time to court, good attitude, smart, and honest. He is respectful and answers all of the questions we had. Two cases were both a...

Gigi

It has been a couple of days since Sam represented my son in Washtenaw County. He gave me the miracle I prayed for. He did way more than I thought was possible and as I told him on the phone I would hug him if I could. If you ever need a good lawyer, this guy is the one to hire – and his prices are...

Linda

Sam took my call and consulted me immediately. He provided fair pricing for the legal services I was requiring. I hired him about a week before my case, he still took on the case load and did amazing work. He is an excellent attorney and a friendly person to be in the court room with when you’re in...

Devon

Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 12 Years of Experience
Fill out the contact form or call us at (734) 883-9584 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message